Skip to content

Evidence-Based Decision Making in Colon and Rectal Surgery

Evidence-Based Decision Making in Colon and Rectal Surgery

Enhanced Recovery Pathways (ERPs)

  • ERPs have gained prominence for improving post-surgical recovery by streamlining care and minimizing complications.
  • Key Elements of ERPs (supported by evidence):
    • Preoperative counseling: Educating patients about the surgery and expected recovery improves outcomes (Grade B).
    • No preoperative fasting: Minimizing fasting reduces complications (Grade A).
    • Avoidance of mechanical bowel preparation: Studies suggest bowel prep is not necessary for all patients and can increase complications (Grade A).
    • Opioid-sparing analgesia: Focus on balanced analgesia with minimal opioid use (Grade A).
    • No nasogastric tubes: Routine nasogastric tubes do not improve outcomes and may delay recovery (Grade A).
    • Fluid restrictions and normothermia: Managing fluids and maintaining body temperature during surgery improve recovery (Grade A).
    • Early feeding and mobilization: Resuming oral intake and encouraging movement soon after surgery reduces hospital stay and improves recovery (Grade A).

Mechanical Bowel Preparation

  • Historically common in colorectal surgery, but its routine use has been questioned.
    • Multiple RCTs have shown no significant benefit and potentially higher rates of complications like anastomotic leaks.
    • However, newer evidence indicates combining mechanical bowel prep with oral antibiotics significantly reduces surgical site infections and anastomotic leaks.
    • Recent studies (2012–2015) suggest this combination leads to fewer infections, ileus, and shorter hospital stays.

Antibiotic Prophylaxis

  • Proven to reduce postoperative wound infections significantly.
    • Prophylactic antibiotics should be administered within 60 minutes before surgical incision (Grade A).
    • Studies support the use of both aerobic and anaerobic coverage for optimal results.
    • Intraoperative redosing may be necessary for longer surgeries or significant blood loss.
    • There is no added benefit of continuing antibiotics beyond 24 hours post-surgery.

Postoperative Oral Intake

  • Traditional practice of delaying oral intake until bowel function returns has little scientific support.
    • Early resumption of oral intake is safe and can reduce hospital stay by approximately one day.
    • Meta-analyses confirm that early feeding does not increase complications such as nausea or anastomotic dehiscence.

Mu-Opioid Receptor Antagonists

  • Alvimopan, an FDA-approved drug, blocks opioid receptors in the gut and reduces the paralytic effects of opioids.
    • Studies have shown that it accelerates gastrointestinal recovery and shortens hospital stay.
    • Despite its benefits, widespread use is limited due to cost, though studies suggest it can reduce overall hospital costs by shortening stays and preventing complications like ileus.

Postoperative Analgesia

  • IV opioids are effective but prolong ileus and delay bowel recovery.
    • Epidural analgesia provides better pain relief and reduces ileus duration but has not consistently shown to shorten hospital stay in enhanced recovery pathways.
    • Thoracic epidurals are recommended for open colorectal surgeries (Grade A), but evidence for laparoscopic surgery is less robust.

Venous Thromboembolic (VTE) Prophylaxis

  • VTE is a common complication after colorectal surgery, even with in-hospital prophylaxis.
    • Guidelines strongly recommend in-hospital use of low-molecular-weight heparin (LMWH) or low-dose unfractionated heparin and intermittent pneumatic compression devices.
    • Extended prophylaxis (4 weeks) is advised for high-risk patients, especially those with cancer. Studies have shown significant reductions in VTE rates with extended prophylaxis.

This structured approach to colorectal surgery, integrating ERPs, selective use of bowel preparation, antibiotic prophylaxis, early postoperative feeding, and thromboembolic prevention, ensures reduced morbidity, shorter hospital stays, and enhanced recovery for patients.

Table 181.1 Components of a Standard Enhanced Recovery Pathway for Colorectal Surgery and the corresponding Level of Evidence for each component:

  • Preoperative Counseling: Grade B
  • Preoperative Feeding (minimization of fasting): Grade A
  • Synbiotics: Not discussed in consensus review
  • No Bowel Preparation: Grade A
  • No Premedication: Grade A
  • Fluid Restriction: Grade A
  • Perioperative High O₂ Concentrations: Not discussed in consensus review
  • Active Prevention of Hypothermia: Grade A
  • Epidural Analgesia: Grade A
  • Minimally Invasive/Transverse Incisions: Grade B
  • No Routine Use of Nasogastric Tubes: Grade A
  • No Use of Drains Above Peritoneal Reflection: Grade A
  • Enforced Postoperative Mobilization: Grade B
  • Enforced Early Postoperative Feeding: Grade A
  • Balanced Analgesia (Multimodal, Low/No Opioids): Grade A
  • Standard Laxatives and Antiemetics: Grade B
  • Early Removal of Urinary Catheter: Not discussed in consensus review

Key Notes:

  • Grade A: Based on high-quality randomized controlled trials (RCTs) or meta-analyses.
  • Grade B: Based on well-conducted clinical studies with lower evidence levels.